I found this song by accident, pretty much; Velvet Crush were an unknown quantity to me in the 1990s when this came out, and I picked it up as much for the title of the album (Teenage Symphonies To God, a Brian Wilson quote) and producer (Matthew Sweet, whom I was heavily into at the time) as anything else. The album itself was agreeable, but nothing too special beyond this cover of a Gene Clark song, which entirely won me over through the aching melody, simplicity of the lyrical plea “Come tell your friend what’s wrong with you?” and arrangement that reminded me, of all things, of Jimmy Webb and Glen Campbell doing “Wichita Lineman” or “Galveston” or something. Looking back, it’s pretty much the kind of thing that would entirely win over the twenty-year-old who was me at the time, but I still can’t hear it honestly now due to all the nostalgia attached to it.
Hearing the 43-year-old original for the first time, the song almost sounds comic with the finger-picking and seemingly rushed vocals. But, goodness and gracious, anyone who doesn’t find a lovely sadness in a chorus that goes “Why don’t you call me your baby anymore?/Am I so changed from some strange love that went before?” may need to check with a doctor to ensure that they still have a heart.